REDIRECT User:Swizzl3d/Sig 09:34, Aug(UTC).If the consensus is support, then the whole thing will be called off and the logo will stay in its current form. I think we'd keep the current logo as a finalist just so people have a chance to maintain the status quo. What will happen if consensus is reached as oppose? Will the current logo still be in the poll? And what will happen if consensus is reached as support? Then we won't even check the new logos that have a chance to be better? bad_fetus talk 09:30, Aug(UTC) Liam - Beta Tester (talk) 09:27, Aug(UTC) I was hoping to keep the same but change the runes to something else like the god symbols and the Godsword associated with the particular god. Oppose - I would like a change in the logo.

Something happened and it worked now so yeh. ʞ o o ɔ 09:24, Aug(UTC)Ĭomment - the link to rhq in the first line doesn't work. It doesn't measure up to the quality standards of the wiki, and pales in comparison to many other fansites' logos. Please note: Oppose means you would like to replace the logo, Support means you like it as is. 9 Do not copy the actual Runescape logo in any way.ʞ o o ɔ 09:24, Aug(UTC)ĭoes anyone mind if I set up a submissions hub at Forum:Changing the logo/Submissions? ʞ o o ɔ 04:39, Aug(UTC) *It occurs to me that we could use Kwik Surveys (as we did in Wiki changes), though someone else may have to coordinate it, and I'm not sure how accurate the results would be. This would be a very bureaucratic, drawn out process that could take more than a month, but I don't know how else to accomplish anything. None of these results would be binding, and if we find that the current logo works, that will be the end of it. It is unfortunate that we have to bypass consensus to narrow down the field, but there is no way that I can think of to use consensus for each of the images that are being submitted (as we may have 50 or more submissions). Use consensus to pick a single finalist (similar to how the FIMG process works, and we would have a separate subpage for each of the finalists).Use polls to narrow down the field, possibly 5-10 semi-finalists (see below)* In addition, have 'comment' sections for each logo.Accept submissions for a new logo (likely on a dedicated page not on the Yew Grove).Decide if the current logo is acceptable.In our attempts to actually get something done and break out of the gridlock, we've worked out a plan: The main reason the previous threads failed was because there was no consensus for any one of the images, though it seemed quite clear that the current logo was unacceptable. I realize we've had our number of Logo threads over the years, but I think the time has come to finally change it. To be honest, (and no offense to those worked on the logo) ours just looks bad. Swiz showed us a picture that RuneHQ had made for the fansite tournament, displaying each of the sites' logos. To discuss the submitted logos, click here.